Rating Benchmarks
How A-E ratings are derived from real-world consumption data. Benchmarks are calculated from 1,738,698 delivery records of 151 European contract-catering restaurants (108 kitchens with delivery data) over 3 years, 2019–2021.
Rating Benchmarks
Ratings reflect a recipe's environmental performance relative to average Swiss consumption. Climate and water each use an independent benchmark derived from sold-portion-weighted averages across a large restaurant panel. Rainforest and animal welfare are rated against fixed criteria instead of a benchmark (see below). The nutrition score (Vita-Score) is shown for information only; it is not part of the scheme. The benchmark is the consumption-weighted average and the upper limit of B: a rating of B or better is below average (a result exactly at the benchmark is a C). A represents a science-based target of 50% below the benchmark.
Computed on database release v1.12.5 (the previous benchmark of record, on v1.12.4, was 2,810.6 g CO2eq/DFU). Ratings use it from the switch after the validation; until then production rates against its previous benchmark. A result exactly on a threshold gets the worse letter.
Climate
| Rating | Threshold |
|---|---|
| A | < 1,325.15 |
| B | < 2,650.3 |
| C | < 5,300.6 |
| D | < 10,601.2 |
| E | ≥ 10,601.2 |
Water Scarcity
| Rating | Threshold |
|---|---|
| A | < 1,483.525 |
| B | < 2,967.05 |
| C | < 5,934.1 |
| D | < 11,868.2 |
| E | ≥ 11,868.2 |
Vita-Score (Nutrition) Not part of the scheme
| Rating | Threshold |
|---|---|
| A | ≤ 270 |
| B | ≤ 340 |
| C | ≤ 410 |
| D | ≤ 450 |
| E | > 450 |
Rainforest and Animal Welfare
Part of the scheme as provider-declared impact categories (ESFC EmpCo Rulebook v1.1, Section 5.6). They are checked differently from climate and water: there is no benchmark. Each rating classifies the rated product's content by origin and certification evidence, in grams per 100 g of the whole product. Only A, B and E are used. A category enters certified scope only with a positive conclusion of the assessment body.
Animal Welfare
| Rating | Rule |
|---|---|
| A | U ≤ 1; any C, including none |
| B | C > 1 and U > 1 |
| E | U > 1 and C ≤ 1 |
Rainforest
| Rating | Rule |
|---|---|
| A | U ≤ 1 and O ≤ 1; any R |
| B | (O > 1 and U ≤ 1) or (R > 1 and U > 1) |
| E | U > 1 and R ≤ 1 |
Amounts of 1.00 g per 100 g or less count as absent. B is an intermediate class: it does not mean that most of the content is certified. The full rules, with worked examples, are in the pathway annex (PA-06.2, Animal Welfare and Rainforest decision rules).
Climate Rating Scale
The rating scale for CO2, showing how thresholds divide the performance range. The benchmark (B/C boundary at 2,650.3 g/DFU) is the consumption-weighted mean of the kitchen benchmark on the Swiss inventory basis, 2026 DFU definition.
Data Coverage
Benchmarks are derived from real contract-catering procurement data: complete delivery records of the sampled kitchens, not menu plans.
How Benchmarks Are Calculated
Daily Food Unit (DFU) is a standardized unit representing one person's daily food intake — the 2026 definition, whose five denominators all derive from one reference person (WHO/FAO 60 kg adult, 2,000 kcal/day). It is calculated as a 5-component average:
rest_energy = energy − 17×protein − 37×fat dry_weight = mass − water − protein − fat
Each component normalizes a nutritional dimension to its daily reference value. Rest-energy and dry weight both strip protein and fat symmetrically, so those two macronutrients are counted exactly once; the 325 g dry-weight reference is the reference person's macro-stripped daily dry matter (carbohydrate 289 g + fibre 25 g + ash 11 g). The DFU ensures fair comparison across food types with different nutritional profiles.
Benchmark calculation: For each metric, the benchmark equals the consumption-weighted average — total impact divided by total DFU delivered — across the observation set. The benchmark of record is measured on real purchasing data: 108 kitchens, three years (2019–2021), 1,738,698 delivery rows on the Swiss (UVEK/BAFU) inventory basis of database release v1.12.5. Numerator and denominator come from the same export: the denominator is the engine's own Daily Food Unit column under the 2026 definition.
Rating thresholds for CO2 and water are derived from each benchmark using the same fixed multipliers: A below 0.5×, B below 1.0× (benchmark), C below 2.0×, D below 4.0×, E from 4.0×; a result exactly on a threshold gets the worse letter. Vita-Score thresholds (for information; not part of the scheme) are derived from DFU-weighted percentiles: A = benchmark × 0.80 (~P10), B = benchmark (~P50), C = P80 (worst 20%), D = P90 (worst 10%).
Derivation record: the full measurement behind the benchmark — every product family, every tonne, traceable to source rows — is maintained as an internal review record and made available to the CAB during the engagement; a client-facing change communication (what moved against the previous ecoinvent basis, and why) is prepared separately.
Cross-Check Against Top-Down Studies
This benchmark is built bottom-up: real purchasing rows × life-cycle inventories. Global studies estimate food-system emissions top-down from emission inventories. The two must agree within their boundary differences; they agree in order of magnitude, and the open points are listed below. The chain below makes the comparison explicit; every step is arithmetic on published figures, not a dietary statement.
| Step | Value | What it does |
|---|---|---|
| Benchmark, per delivered DFU | 2,650.3 g CO2eq | Consumption-weighted mean of the kitchen sample (food as purchased, kitchen and plate waste inside) |
| × 365 days | 0.967 t / year | One reference-person year at exactly 2,000 kcal/day of delivered food |
| × 2,985 / 2,000 kcal | 1.44 t / year | Scaled to the actual global per-capita food supply (FAO Food Balance Sheets, 2022). The supply figure already contains consumer-stage food waste — UNEP measures 19% of consumer-available food wasted (households 60% of it) — so waste must not be added again on top of intake scaling |
| × 3,471 / 2,000 kcal | 1.68 t / year | Same scaling at the European supply level — the highest regional DES in 2022 (FAO: 3,471 kcal/cap/day), closer to this benchmark's European catering basket |
| Top-down reference | 2.2 t / year | EDGAR-FOOD (EU JRC, 2024 update, data year 2023): 18 Gt CO2eq — one third of global GHG emissions — over the world population |
The residual (about 34 % on the world basis) is in the direction the boundary differences predict, but most of it is not yet attributed. EDGAR-FOOD counts stages this delivered-food benchmark does not carry in full: end-of-life waste management (6% of the food-system total), domestic food preparation (~2%), the full breadth of land-use-change accounting, and refrigerant F-gases (4%) — and it averages the world's diets, while this benchmark measures a European contract-catering basket. A further 13% of food is lost between harvest and retail (FAO); those upstream losses are largely embedded in the life-cycle inventories themselves. An independent bottom-up measurement landing below the top-down world average is expected from these differences; how much of the gap they explain is not yet measured (U1). (UNEP attributes 8–10% of global GHG emissions to food loss and waste alone — consistent with the waste-related wedge of this residual.) The named wedges quantify to at most ~0.27 t of the 0.76 t world-basis residual. What remains open is stated here rather than absorbed into the narrative:
- U1 — Unattributed share: the named wedges (end-of-life 0.134 t, domestic preparation 0.051 t, F-gases 0.088 t) cover at most ~0.27 t of the 0.76 t residual; at least ~0.5 t is currently unattributed.
- U2 — Boundary double-claim (the annex statement yielded, 28 September 2026): the pathway annex used to declare cradle-to-grave coverage including end-of-life. Pathway annex PA-07.4 now declares the operated boundary: Eaternity Gastro ratings run from agricultural production to delivery at the kitchen; end-of-life and the consumer phase are excluded, and kitchen preparation is not systematically modelled (open point: tag-triggered heat treatment, to be confirmed). The end-of-life and domestic-preparation wedges can therefore explain part of the residual, subject to that open point and to an inventory-level check of whether matched inventories embed such flows.
- U3 — Basket direction: Europe's more animal-heavy supply (77.7 vs 44.5 kg meat/cap/yr, FAO) should raise per-kcal intensity above the world average, yet the European-scaled figure (1.68 t) sits below the world top-down (2.2 t); the compensating forces are plausible but unquantified.
- U4 — GWP metric vintage: EDGAR-FOOD's GWP100 basis is unverified against our EF 3.1 / AR6 characterisation (35% CH4 share ⇒ several-percent sensitivity).
- U5 — Missing like-for-like comparator: a European per-capita top-down figure from EDGAR-FOOD's country data would turn U1/U3 into arithmetic — the cheapest item to close.
- U6 — kcal-only scaling: the supply scaling treats one DFU as 2,000 kcal; the DFU also normalises protein, fat, water and dry matter — a sensitivity check on pure kcal is defined.
None of these endangers the order-of-magnitude conclusion; each carries its resolution path in the evidence dossier, and the list shrinks — never silently — as items close.
Sources: Crippa et al. 2021, Nature Food (food systems = one third of global GHG emissions); EDGAR-FOOD, EU Joint Research Centre (2024 update: 18 Gt in 2023; 2.2 t CO2eq per person); FAO Food Balance Sheets 2010–2022 (global dietary energy supply 2,985 kcal/cap/day, 2022); UNEP Food Waste Index Report 2024 (19% of consumer-available food wasted; FAO: 13% lost post-harvest to pre-retail); Poore & Nemecek 2018, Science (independent bottom-up global estimate: 13.7 Gt CO2eq, 26% share). The comparison is a reference-frame reconciliation between system boundaries; none of these figures is a statement about what any person eats or should eat. Every claim above is documented with its verbatim source quote, access date and archive hash in the evidence dossier.